Log In or Sign Up now and we’ll give you $125 to spend on fishing gear.

Search form

Costilla Creek, NM Fishing Report

My Current Water
Fish Caught by Users
Waters
Fishing Spots
Fishhound Pro Staff
USGS Stations
NOAA Stations
Premium Map Layers
Pro Catch Report
Coastline Contours
Javascript is required to view this map.
Additional Reports
< Prev Next >
Request Updated Report
Filter Reports By:
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
3
Provided by The Reel Life
Last Updated: 08/30/2012
Discounts and Promotions | Book Guide Service

Midweek is best, double dry. I'd use a caddis followed by a black parachute.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
4

Trout fishing was very good using small hoppers, tan, brown and olive elk hair caddis and PMDs. Through the Valle Vidal the Costilla and Comanche Creek continued to fish well. 
 

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
3

Trout fishing was good using hoppers, black and olive elk hair caddis, brassies and yellow sallys. Through the Valle Vidal the Costilla and Comanche Creek continued to fish well. 
 

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
1

The flow is 11 cfs near the town of Costilla. Fishing is reported as slow below the Valle Vidal boundary, water levels are very low and there is snow and ice.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 11 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
1

The flow is 6.4 cfs near the town of Costilla. Fishing is reported as slow below the Valle Vidal boundary, water levels are very low and fish are spooky.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 6.4 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
1

The flow is 12 cfs near the town of Costilla. Fishing is reported as slow below the Valle Vidal boundary. Anglers are having success with dry droppers and various bed headed nymphs close to the banks. Check the flows before you go, water levels are very low and fish are spooky.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 12 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
1

The flow is 10 cfs near the town of Costilla. Fishing is reported as slow below the Valle Vidal boundary. Anglers are having success with dry droppers and various bed headed nymphs close to the banks. Check the flows before you go. Water levels are very low and fish are spooky.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
Good
11AM - 6PM
Fair
6PM - 12AM
Fair
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
1

The flow is 7.4 cfs near the town of Costilla. Fishing is reported as slow below the Valle Vidal boundary. Anglers are having success with dry droppers and various bed headed nymphs close to the banks. Check the flows before you go, water levels are very low and fish are spooky.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 7.4 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
1

The release has lowered to near zero and unless you are fishing below the Valle Vidal boundary, the Costilla is done. Put this palce on your list for next summer when the Valle Vidal will reopen on July 1st.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 7.4 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
2

The flow is 10 cfs near the town of Costilla. Fishing is reported as fair. Anglers are having success with dry droppers close to the banks. Check the flows before you go.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 10 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
2

The release has lowered to near zero and unless you are fishing below the Valle Vidal boundary, the Costilla is done. Put this palce on your list for next summer when the Valle Vidal will reopen on July 1st.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 7.4 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
2

The flow is 15 cfs near the town of Costilla and 20 cfs at the dam. Fishing is reported as fair to slow with the low flows. The release has lowered to a point where the fishing is going to be tough, at least above Comanche Creek anyway. Check the flows before you go.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
2

The release has lowered to a point where the fishing is going to be tough, at least above Commanche Creek anyway. Check the flows before you go. I anticipate that the release is actually going to be reduced to zero for the winter. The upper pond at Shuree Ponds is quite low and weedy. Better reports from the lower pond.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 7.4 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
2

The flow is 16 cfs near the town of Costilla and 12 cfs at the dam. Fishing is reported as fair to slow with the low flows. Various bead headed nymphs, stimulators with droppers and dry flies are catching the fish right now. The river was stocked last week with 381 triploid rainbow trout.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
2

The flow is 18 cfs near the town of Costilla and 16 cfs at the dam. Fishing is reported as fair with various bead headed nymphs, stimulators with droppers and dry flies. The release is a bit low. Expect the fish to utilize whatever cover is available which in some cases is right up against the bank or in the deeper holes.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
2

The release is lower than I'd like to see, but this special stream is definitely worth visiting at least once a summer. Expect the fish to utilize whatever cover is available which in most cases is right up against the bank. The upper pond at Shuree Ponds is quite low and weedy. Better reports from the lower pond.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 29 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
3

The flow is 26 cfs near the town of Costilla and 29 cfs at the dam. Fishing is reported as good with various bead-headed nymphs, stimulators with droppers and dry flies. The release is at a good level. Expect the fish to utilize whatever cover is available which in some cases is right up against the bank. The river was stocked last week with 400 triploid rainbow trout.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
3

The release is at a good level. Expect the fish to utilize whatever cover is avaiable which in most cases is right up against the bank. The upper pond at Shuree Ponds is quite low and weedy. Better reports from the lower pond.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 49 CFS No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
3

The flow is 43 cfs near the town of Costilla and 41 cfs at the dam. Fishing is reported as good with various bead headed nymphs, stimulators with droppers and dry flies. The release is at a good level. Expect the fish to utilize whatever cover is available which in some cases is right up against the bank.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. No rating.
Pro's Overall Rating for this Water:
3

The release is at a good level. Expect the fish to utilize whatever cover is avaiable which in some cases is right up against the bank. the upper pond at Shuree Ponds is quite low and weedy. Better reports from the lower pond.

Best Time to Fish
Morning Afternoon Evening
3AM - 11AM
No Data Available
11AM - 6PM
No Data Available
6PM - 12AM
No Data Available
Water Data
Clarity Temp Flow Flow Best Tide
No rating. Fahrenheit No rating. 40 CFS No rating.

Photos

No photos.

+ Add Photo

Videos

No videos.

+ Add Video

Alerts

Recent Published

July 20, 2011 at 6:00pm | Report Abuse

post a comment